Checked 2026-11-16

beehiiv vs Substack: what you really pay

Substack costs nothing to send but keeps 10% of revenue + credit card fees. beehiiv charges a monthly price by list size and takes 0% of paid subscriptions (Lite and Pro).

beehiiv's free plan goes up to 2,500 subscribers.

beehiiv

Price depends on subscribers (1,000, 2,500, 5,000, 10,000, 25,000, 50,000, 75,000, 100,000, 150,000, 200,000, 250,000+). Free up to 2,500; Lite up to 100,000; Pro up to 250,000.

beehiiv pricing · beehiiv alternatives

Try free
Substack

Free to use at any list size; Substack takes 10% of paid-subscription revenue, plus card processing fees.

Substack alternatives

Try free

Price at your list size

Cheapest paid plan that fits, per month. "Billed yearly" is the yearly price shown per month.

Subscribersbeehiivbilled monthlySubstackbilled monthlybeehiivbilled yearlySubstackbilled yearly
500Free plan fits$59/mo (Lite)$0 (10% of revenue + credit card fees)$49/mo (Lite)—
1,000Free plan fits$59/mo (Lite)$0 (10% of revenue + credit card fees)$49/mo (Lite)—
2,500Free plan fits$79/mo (Lite)$0 (10% of revenue + credit card fees)$69/mo (Lite)—
5,000$109/mo (Lite)$0 (10% of revenue + credit card fees)$95/mo (Lite)—
10,000$139/mo (Lite)$0 (10% of revenue + credit card fees)$119/mo (Lite)—
25,000$199/mo (Lite)$0 (10% of revenue + credit card fees)$169/mo (Lite)—
50,000$299/mo (Lite)$0 (10% of revenue + credit card fees)$249/mo (Lite)—

Green = cheaper at that size (billed monthly). Sources: beehiiv's pricing page and Substack's pricing page, checked 2026-11-16.

Running a paid newsletter

What you keep each month with 2,500 subscribers on your list, if paying readers bring in this much (subscriptions at $5 a month). Plan price, the platform's fee and card processing fees are all taken off.

Paid revenue per monthYou keep on beehiivYou keep on Substack
$500$377Lite $79 · fee $0 · card $44.50$406Free $0 · fee $50 · card $44.50
$2,000$1,743Lite $79 · fee $0 · card $178$1,622Free $0 · fee $200 · card $178
$5,000$4,476Lite $79 · fee $0 · card $445$4,055Free $0 · fee $500 · card $445

Fees: beehiiv 0% take rate on paid subscriptions (Lite and Pro); Substack 10% of revenue + credit card fees. Card fees: 2.9% + $0.30 per payment (Stripe's standard processing fee, as stated on beehiiv's pricing page (checked 2026-11-16)). Try your own numbers on the newsletter platforms page →

Plans and limits

beehiivSubstack
Price based onsubscriberssubscribers
Free planup to 2,500 subscribers, with beehiiv branding in your emailsUnlimited emails
Free trial14 daysNo
Billingyearly or monthlymonthly
Paid plansLite, Pro—
Custom quote above250,000 subscribers—
Current deal——

Features

FeaturebeehiivSubstack
AutomationsFrom LiteFree: a welcome email only; Lite: 10 live automations; Pro: unlimited.?
A/B testingFrom LiteAll plansSubject line test, from 200 subscribers.
Signup forms & pop-upsAll plansAll plansEmbeddable signup form (not customizable).
Landing pagesAll plansFree: 1 custom page; Lite: 10; Pro: unlimited (website builder).?
Paid newsletterFrom Lite0% take rate; Lite: 1 paid tier, Pro: unlimited.All plansSubstack keeps 10% plus Stripe fees.
No tool branding in emailsFrom Pro?

Only features verified on each vendor's own pages; "?" = not verified yet (not "no"). Hover a cell for its source.

Which should you pick?

Rules worked out from the prices and features on both vendors' own pages, nothing else.

Where the prices jump

Both tools raise the price in steps as your list grows. These are the biggest steps on each tool's cheapest plan at 2,500 subscribers:

beehiiv Lite · billed monthly
  • $79 → $109 when you pass 2,500 (+38%)
  • $139 → $199 when you pass 10,000 (+43%)
  • $199 → $299 when you pass 25,000 (+50%)
Substack

No list-size steps: Substack is free to send at any size. The 10% fee grows with your paid income instead.

Switching between beehiiv and Substack

beehiiv vs Substack FAQ

Do beehiiv and Substack have a free plan?

beehiiv: yes: up to 2,500 subscribers, with beehiiv branding in your emails. Substack: yes: Unlimited emails.

Which takes less of my paid newsletter income, beehiiv or Substack?

beehiiv: 0% take rate on paid subscriptions (Lite and Pro). Substack: 10% of revenue + credit card fees. With $2,000 a month in paid subscriptions ($5 each) and 2,500 subscribers, you keep about $1,743 on beehiiv and $1,622 on Substack, after plan price, platform fee and card fees.

Does beehiiv or Substack help me move my list?

beehiiv: not verified yet. Substack: not verified yet.

Which has a free trial, beehiiv or Substack?

beehiiv: 14-day free trial, no card, plus a free plan. Substack: no free trial, free to use.

How do beehiiv and Substack count my list?

beehiiv: Price depends on subscribers (1,000, 2,500, 5,000, 10,000, 25,000, 50,000, 75,000, 100,000, 150,000, 200,000, 250,000+). Free up to 2,500; Lite up to 100,000; Pro up to 250,000. Substack: Free to use at any list size; Substack takes 10% of paid-subscription revenue, plus card processing fees.

All tools by price · Add a third tool side by side · How we check prices